Chaim Albert Shul
LOCKED-OUT
The Chaim Albert Synagogue is located within the Kingsbrook Jewish Medical Center ("KJMC") and has been locked out after nearly a century of being a free shul open to the public for religious services.
The COVID 19 government emergency orders had temporarily suspended access to the hospital synagogue back in 2020.
Additionally, the main hospital entrance to the shul (by Rutland & E 49th) was sold off in December'23 by the hospital for affordable housing, sponsored by NYS Empire State Development ("NYS ESD") under Vital Brooklyn's "Kingsbrook Estates". The developer and NYS ESD both promised the Jews that they would have uninterrupted access to their synagogue from other entrances. The hospital was a $26 million dollar beneficiary and very much aware (constructive notice) of the aforementioned promises / representations that were part of the NYS ESD Request for Proposal process preceding the sale of the northern part of Kingsbrook Medical Center abutting Rutland Rd.
After the COVID 19 emergency orders expired in June'23, the Jews wanted back in to their shul. They asked the hospital for the access to the shul that was previously promised through entrances. The answer by the hospital is now nisht, (NO) and the not for profit hospital refuses to say who authorized such an order. Was there a Board of Director's resolution? A not for profit hospital, who serves the public interest must be more transparent with who gave the order to close the shul.
Why is a 96 yr old synagogue, built by Jews and for Jews being destroyed in the name of building future affordable housing? Why isn't it being PROTECTED and PRESERVED? Why is the public in the dark as to who at the hospital gave the orders?
So the new construction at Kingsbrook Jewish will help the homeless get off the sidewalk and get a roof over their heads, while the Jews get pushed to the sidewalk and will pray under the rain. The Jews at Kingsbrook are used to the rain over their heads, since the synagogue roof has not been replaced by hospital despite OBH getting $700 million in taxpayer funds in 2021.
The Shul has served the community for decades and been kept alive by the faithful persistence of members who have went out of their way to keep the weekly minyans going. The Chaim Albert Synagogue is a separate stand alone building tand is named after the father of the shul's founder and past hospital president, Isaac Albert. The Chaim Albert Synagogue built in 1950, was meant to replace the original interior Jewish shul that was built inside the hospital in 1928. The design and purpose of the 1928 Kingsbrook Shul as well as the 1950 Chaim Albert Synagogue was to be a "place of prayer and meditation". NYS law follows the Cy Pres doctrine which requires that the existing charitable uses (Jewish prayer and meditation and a hospital chapel open to all) of the donor/founder must be continued or else the asset (synagogue) must be given to an entity (congregation) that continues the same charitable uses and purposes (Jewish prayer and meditation, and a hospital chapel open to all).
The 1927 opening of the hospital as a hospital built for Jews, to escape the anti-semitism of Kings County Hospital, with kosher food and a religious atmosphere. "Generous support will enable the Jewish institution to serve Jewish incurables, alleviating to a greater degree their suffering and hardships with kosher food and a religious and racial atmosphere likely to make them feel more at ease." ( The Chat, p.5, July 2, 1927)
The shul is also special since it is a "FREE Shul" that has no membership fees and is therefore a vital community facility open to the public. The shul also functions as the hospital's chapel.
The shul has been "constructively evicted" (denied access) by One Brooklyn Health ("OBH") breaking ninety six years (since 1928) of Jewish worship and prayer inside the hospital.
The northern half of Kingsbrook Jewish Medical center was recently sold on December 13, 2023 to Monadnock Development as part of NYS Homes and Community Renewal's ("NYS HCR") Vital Brooklyn "Kingsbrook Estates". The development involved taking away the Rutland entrance to the shul, while promising alternative synagogue access. Kingsbrook Shul members relied upon the NYS HCR representation on January 2, 2019 that "access to the synagogue will be preserved throughout and after the development is complete."
The NYC COVID 19 Public Health Emergency ("PHE") was the reason KJMC originally temporarily suspended access to the shul.
NYC's COVID 19 public health emergency orders expired on June 20, 2023.
Members of the Kingsbrook Shul are still being denied access, even though the COVID emergency orders have expired, and even though NYS HCR and the developer represented that the Shul would remain open during Vital Brooklyn construction.
The Jews who founded Kingsbrook Jewish Medical Center about a century ago would be turning over in their graves if they found out that a few months after the hospital sold off it's northern buildings and the shul's main ( Rutland Rd) entrance for $27 million, the hospital would go back on its word for continued access (through Winthrop St) and instead turn the shul into a storage room for garbage pails.
On April 12, 2018, the Board of Kingsbrook Jewish Medical Center ("KJMC") was replaced by the Board of the "System" or the future board of One Brooklyn Health ("OBH"). On Jan 1, 2021, Kingsbrook Jewish Medical Center Corp was merged out of existence and joined Brookdale Hospital and Interfaith Hospitals to be part of "One Brooklyn Health". Legally KJMC and Interfaith merged into Brookdale Hospital.
The hospital is empty as a result of hospital department closings, yet the shul is asked to come up with money to build new bathrooms when the Minkin building already has alternate hallway bathrooms that the Shul had access to before.
It is this website's personal opinion that demanding new bathrooms be built in a failing old hospital with less bathroom use is a pretext to getting rid of the shul, which violates NYC Human Rights law requiring reasonable accomodations for public accomodations and also the Cy Pres doctrine of non-profits requiring the continuation of existing charitable uses after a merger or else being required to then give the property back to an organization with a substantially similar activity.
Fair Use Disclosure​
The purpose of this website is to inform the user about the Chaim Albert Synagogue, One Brooklyn Health, Vital Brooklyn projects in East Flatbush , and about various cultures in East Flatbush through interviews, documentaries and music videos. Any statements made about OBH are personal opinions of this website. This website does not charge or advertise any professional services and is a FREE Public Service Announcement with an informational and educational purpose.
​
The Copyright Laws of the United States recognize a "fair use" of copyrighted content. Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act states:
​
"Notwithstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work,
including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords or by any other means specified by that section, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright."
​
This website may contain copyrighted works that were not specifically authorized to be used by the copyrighted holder(s) , but which I believe in good faith are protected by federal law and the fair use doctrine for one or more of the reasons noted above.
If any person has any specific concerns about this website or our position on the fair use defense, please contact us by emailing us at jaysorid@aol.com.